•  
  •  
 

Abstract

In recent months, protesters and observers have filed several class actions seeking to enjoin Department of Homeland Security (DHS) agents from violating their rights under the First and Fourth Amendments. Despite broad agreement that constitutional violations are taking place, some of the courts hearing those cases have deemed class-wide preliminary injunctive relief to be appropriate, while others have not. The biggest stumbling blocks have been the commonality prerequisite to class certification and the Supreme Court’s recent prohibition against universal injunctions.

As this Article explains, much of the confusion in these cases—and in other putative class actions seeking injunctive or declaratory relief—has arisen from a conflation of the requirements for certifying Rule 23(b)(3) class actions for damages and Rule 23(b)(2) class actions for non-monetary relief. Because Rule 23(b)(3) class actions ultimately require the court to determine the amount of money due to each class member, the class certification inquiry is backward-looking and focuses on individual class members’ past experiences. By contrast, these types of Rule 23(b)(2) class actions ultimately require the court to determine whether to issue prospective relief against the defendant, so the certification inquiry is forward-looking and focuses on the defendant’s ongoing or future conduct.

Appreciating these differences would improve courts’ analysis of class certification and class-wide preliminary injunctive relief, both in this current set of cases and in other actions seeking to enjoin alleged violations of constitutional rights. Conversely, when combined with the prohibition against universal injunctions, applying a damages frame to Rule 23(b)(2) class actions could contribute to a scenario in which government actors commit flagrant and widespread constitutional violations, but the judiciary declares itself powerless to stop them.

Share

COinS
 
 

To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.