Document Type
Response or Comment
Publication Title
Journal of Medical Ethics
Publication Date
2022
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1136/medethics-2021-107472
Abstract
In ’The Complex Case of Ellie Anderson’, Joona Rasanen and Anna Smajdor raise several ethical questions about the case. One question asks, but does not answer, whether Ellie faced discrimination for being transgender when her mother was not allowed access to Ellie’s sperm following her death. In raising the question, the authors imply anti-trans bias may have influenced this determination. However, this inference is not supported by current ethical and legal guidance for posthumous use of gametes, with which Ellie’s case is consistent. We consider the authors’ responses to their other ethical queries, and how their suggestions for what options might have been available to Ellie and her family are instructive for addressing attempts in the USA and UK to restrict minors’ access to gender-affirming medical treatment, including puberty-blocking therapy.
Recommended Citation
Elizabeth Lanphier & Shannon Fyfe, Age—Not Sex or Gender—Makes the Case of Ellie Anderson Complex, 48 J. Med. Ethics 266 (2022).